Hadith Contradiction Hadith

কোৰআন-৯:৩১

সিহঁতে আল্লাহৰ বাহিৰে সিহঁতৰ পণ্ডিত আৰু সংসাৰ-বিৰাগিসকলক সিহঁতৰ ৰবৰূপে গ্ৰহণ কৰিছে আৰু মাৰইয়ামৰ পুত্ৰ মছীহকো। অথচ এক ইলাহৰ ইবাদত কৰাৰ বাবেই তেওঁলোক আদিষ্ট হৈছিল। যাৰ বাহিৰে আন কোনো সত্য ইলাহ নাই। সিহঁতে যি অংশী স্থাপন কৰে তাৰ পৰা তেওঁ অতি পৱিত্ৰ!

.

কোৰআন-২:১৭০

আৰু যেতিয়া সিহঁতক কোৱা হয়, ‘আল্লাহে যি অৱতীৰ্ণ কৰিছে সেয়া তোমালোকে অনুসৰণ কৰা’, (তেতিয়া) সিহঁতে কয়, ‘নহয়, বৰং আমি অনুসৰণ কৰিম সেইটোৰ, যিটোৰ ওপৰত আমি আমাৰ পিতৃ পুৰুষসকলক পাইছো’। যদিও সিহঁতৰ পিতৃ-পুৰুষসকলে একো বুজা নাছিল আৰু সিহঁত সৎপথতো পৰিচালিত নাছিল, (তথাপিও সিহঁতে তাৰেই অনুসৰণ কৰিব নে?)

।।।

Please note, these two reports are given in almost all hadith books and are graded as Sahih.

“Do not write down anything from me except the holy Quran and those who have written must wipe them out.” Reference: Taqyid al-‘ilm P 29-31, Musnad Ahmad vol. 3 P 12, 21, 39, Sunan al-Darimi vol:1. 

The statement is very clear and it does not need any interpretations. It simply prohibits writing down of Hadith. Even those who had written some Hadith down had been made responsible to wipe them out.  

Note: Who make Islamic law from any extra-Quranic Book such as Hadiths and Sunna etc. has been declared by Allah, as Zaalim, Faasiq and Kaafirs in Quran 5:40-5:48. Quran 6:114, 10:15, 7:3, 25:30, 16:116, 50:45, 7:3 also make VERY CLEAR that Islamic law (Sharia law) is valid Only and Only from Quran. Quran makes very clear that to Obey Allah and his Messenger mean nothing else but to follow Quran 6:114, 10:15, 47:2. No other Book/source  for Islamic Sharia except Quran 6:114. Please note: Darimi is one of the Biggest demigods of Hadithers because Darimi was teacher of Bukhari, Muslim, Abu Dawud, Ibn Maja, Tirmidhi, Nasaaei, and many others.